Kathy Bazoian Phelps
Senior Counsel in Ponzi Scheme Litigation
and Bankruptcy Matters

Kathy is a senior business trial attorney with more than 30 years experience prosecuting and defending claims for high net worth clients involved in Ponzi scheme matters and in bankruptcy proceedings. Kathy’s practice includes recovering assets for clients in complex fraud cases under standard fee and alternative fee arrangements. She also handles SEC and CFTC whistleblower claims. Kathy also serves as a mediator in bankruptcy matters, in complex business disputes, and in matters requiring detailed knowledge about fraud or Ponzi schemes.

Kathy’s Clients in Ponzi Scheme Cases and Bankruptcy Matters
Equity Receivers
Bankruptcy Trustees
High Net Worth Investors
Whistleblowers
Debtors in Bankruptcy
Secured and Unsecured Creditors

Wednesday, October 10, 2012

Fraudulent Transfer Claim Meets Forfeiture Proceeding in Ponzi Scheme Case

Posted by Kathy Bazoian Phelps

It occasionally happens that a trustee seeks to avoid a debtor’s prepetition transfer of property as a fraudulent transfer and that property is also subject to a government forfeiture proceeding. In that event, can the trustee still follow the familiar path and file an adversary proceeding in the bankruptcy court, or must the trustee jump into unfamiliar territory and file a petition in forfeiture proceeding in the district court?

A recent opinion coming out of the Scott Rothstein Ponzi scheme case concludes that in these circumstances, the trustee must pursue the fraudulent transfer claim in the forfeiture process and that the trustee’s attempt to pursue it in the bankruptcy court after the entry of a final order of forfeiture is barred by res judicata. Stettin v. Alu (In re Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler, P.A.), 2012 Bankr. LEXIS 4472 (Bankr. S.D. Fla. Aug. 29, 2012). In that case, the trustee in the bankruptcy case of Rothstein’s law firm sought to avoid a transfer of $301,000 that the law firm had made to the bodyguard of Rothstein’s wife to enable him to purchase a home. The bodyguard and his wife, Joseph and Jody Alu, executed a note and a mortgage to Fifth Court LLC, an entity owned by Rothstein. The trustee also sought to avoid that note and mortgage.

The assets of Fifth Court, however, were the subject of a district court forfeiture order in Rothstein’s criminal case, stating that Rothstein forfeited “[a]ll right, title and interest in Fifth Court and all assets held by or owed to it.” In the meantime, the Alus interpled with the bankruptcy court sufficient funds to pay off the mortgage. As a result, the dispute over those funds was really between the trustee and the government – fraudulent transfer claim v. forfeiture order.

The government, relying on the specific language of the forfeiture order, contended that the trustee’s claim was a collateral attack upon it. The trustee argued that he was not collaterally attacking the forfeiture order or challenging government’s claim to Fifth Court and its assets but rather was asserting that Fifth Court, and therefore the government, had no claim to the interpled funds because the note and mortgage were invalid.

The bankruptcy court found for the government and dismissed the trustee’s fraudulent transfer claim. The court held that an ancillary proceeding under 21 U.S.C. § 853(n) “is the exclusive means for a third party to claim an interest in forfeited property.” The court also noted that § 853(k) prohibits a third party from commencing an action at law or equity against the government concerning the validity of an alleged interest in the property outside of an ancillary proceeding. Because the trustee could have filed a petition in the ancillary proceeding asserting his fraudulent transfer claim and the invalidity of the note and mortgage but did not, the final order of forfeiture extinguished the trustee’s claim.

Interestingly, the trustee had actually filed a petition in the forfeiture action, but only seeking the imposition of a constructive trust over Fifth Court for an amount equal to funds that the law firm had transferred to the Alus. The district court, however, had dismissed that claim. It is unclear why the trustee had not asserted his fraudulent transfer claim in the same petition. According to the bankruptcy court, that is precisely what the trustee should have done.

The bankruptcy court’s decision on this issue is not an anomaly. It is consistent with prior case law. See, e.g., Uecker & Assocs., Inc. v. L.G. Hunt & Assocs., Inc. (In re American Basketball League, Inc.), 317 B.R. 121, 128 (Bankr. N.D. Cal. 2004) (holding that upon entry of the final order of forfeiture, the government held good title to sales proceeds as substitute res and no petition had been filed in the ancillary proceedings under 21 U.S.C. § 853(n) so the fraudulent transfer claim to recover the proceeds was barred outside of the forfeiture action under § 853(k)).

The lesson for bankruptcy trustees from these cases is clear: Any avoidance action directed at forfeited property must be made in the forfeiture action under 21 U.S.C. § 853(n) and not in the bankruptcy court. Even though this will obviously be more challenging for trustees and their counsel and probably outside of their comfort zones, their failure to abide this lesson will likely mean the loss of the fraudulent claim to the detriment of the creditors of the estate.

Sunday, September 30, 2012

September 2012 Ponzi Scheme Roundup

 Posted by Kathy Bazoian Phelps
September was another busy month for Ponzi scheme news. Here is the summary of the stories that were reported this month. Please feel free to post comments about other Ponzi schemes that I may have missed. And please remember that I am just relaying what’s in the news, not writing or verifying it.
Angelo A. Alleca, 42, and Summit Wealth Management Inc., based in Atlanta, were the subject of a complaint filed by the SEC seeking an asset freeze in connection with their sale of interests in Summit Fund. It is alleged that Alleca and Summit Wealth Management sold interests in Summit Fund, which they told their clients was operating as a “fund-of-funds” – meaning they were investing their money in other funds and investment products rather than directly in stocks and other securities. Alleca instead allegedly engaged in active securities trading with his clients’ money, and he incurred substantial losses. He concealed the Summit Fund trading losses from investors and provided them false account statements.
Willard Aller and Bonnie Aller have pleaded no contest to charges in connection with a Ponzi scheme they had allegedly operated through their company, Malibu East Motor Cars. Under the terms of the plea agreement, Will and Bonnie Aller will serve 10 years of supervised probation and pay at least $234,000 to victims who said they never got the money they invested in what they thought were high-interest car loans for people with poor credit.
Nikolai Battoo and his companies BC Captial Group SA (based in Panama) and BC Capital Group Ltd. (based in Hong Kong) were the subject of an emergency action by the SEC to obtain a freeze of the U.S.-based assets belong to Battoo and his companies. Battoo and his companies operated feeder funds for Bernard Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, and it is alleged that Battoo raised at least $100 million from U.S. investors by overstating the value of his investments, among other things. Battoo blamed the collapse of MF Global for his inability to pay redemptions requested by investors. In a separate complaint, the CFTC is also seeking an asset freeze and appointment of a receiver. Tracy Lee Sunderlage, who allegedly helped Battoo raise money, was also charged.
Stephen B. Blankenship, 63, pleaded guilty to a $600,000 Ponzi scheme that he operated through his company, Deer Hill Investment Group. He defrauded about a dozen investors, many of whom were elderly members of his church, by taking their money to supposedly invest at higher rates of return than they had been receiving. He prepared false statements showing that his clients’ accounts were increasing in value.
Daniel Bogar, Bernerd Young, and Jason Green, were charged in administrative proceedings brought by the SEC in connection with their role in the Ponzi scheme of Allen Stanford. The SEC alleged that they knew or should have known that offering documents in connection with the certificates of deposits sold by Stanford International Bank were false or misleading. Jay Comeaux settled with the SEC’s administrative proceedings against him without admitting or denying the SEC’s allegation. Comeaux had been responsible for supervising financial consultants and had received commissions of at least $1.3 million.
Ronald Lee Brito, 61, Bonnie Brito, 66, and Thomas Winston Moore, 68, of California were arrested on charges relating to an alleged $25 million investment scheme. The case will be prosecuted in Michigan since most of the approximately 500 victims were from Michigan, recruited by John James Missitti of Michigan. Missitti and Mark Carpenter were also named in the indictment. The five defendants promised investors large returns on their investments in, among other things, valuable minerals extracted from a gold mine in Arizona. They used various corporate names to run the scheme, including Infinity Trading, LLC, GetMoni.com, and PJM Kingman Mine.
Mark Casolo, 55, a former stockbroker for McGinn, Smith & Co, was arraigned on allegations that he stole about $2.2 million from 16 victims in a 3 year Ponzi scheme. Casolo pleaded not guilty to charges that he duped clients into investing their life savings with him. Casolo used the companies Escalation Capital Group, LTD, Wilderness Partners, LLC, Wilderness Capital Group, and NCH Partners, LLC to run his scam.
Nicholas Cosmo saw his 25 year prison sentence upheld on appeal. Cosmo ran a $413 million Ponzi scheme through Agape World Inc. and Agape Merchant Advance LLC in which he told investors he would use their money to make short term loans. He claimed that the loans would be secured by borrowers’ assets and promised returns as high as 80 percent.
Lydia Cladek, 68, of Florida was sentenced to 30 years in prison for her role in a $50 to $100 million Ponzi scheme that she operated through her company, Lydia Cladek Inc. Cladek bought sub-prime automobile finance contracts from dealers at discounted prices and then promised investors a large slice of the income from the notes’ interest rates, which often exceeded 20 percent. Cladek used the investors’ funds on a variety of luxuries, including 12 houses, most of which were used for investment purposes. Cladek had three vacation homes, lived in a gated community in St. Augustine Beach and had $2,000-sheets on her bed. Cladek also made substantial donations to various animal shelters or rescue operations. The court noted that Cladek showed no remorse, and the 30 year sentence may be the largest ever given to a female accused of operating a Ponzi scheme.
Michael Todd Crosswhite, 42, received a 2 year, 9 month sentence and agreed to pay more than $940,000 in restitution to his victims. Crosswhite victimized 9 people and one business working under the name of Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America. Crosswhite was an independent agent of Allianz, held himself out as a financial consultant, and was selling insurance products for other companies.
Ramon DeSage, a businessman in Las Vegas, is accused of using his companies, including Cadeau Express to defraud investors of millions of dollars. Tara Mazzeo, 36, of Las Vegas, is accused of lying to IRS agents about her financial ties to DeSage, including of lying about receiving almost $500,000 from DeSage in 2009 to help buy a home and a luxury vehicle, and about the transfer of $350,000 from DeSage’s bank accounts to Mazzeo’s business, Tarabella LLC.
Marino De Silva, 51, a Los Angeles-based and U.K. born guitarist, is facing up to 8 years in jail after pleading guilty to charges relating to his taking millions of dollars from investors, using his company Angels on Earth Foundation as a front for raising money for causes such as wounded American troops and kids with autism. De Silva allegedly operated the company in a Ponzi scheme fashion but never gave the money to the charities he was supposedly helping. DeSilva claimed to own rights to rare recordings and interviews by iconic bands such as the Rolling Stones, the Beatles, and Carlos Santana. Investors were solicited to assist in the digital re-mastering of the recordings which, once released, would supposedly be in high demand and produce lucrative returns. However, when the purported “re-mastered” albums were released, they turned out to be nothing more than poor quality cover versions of already-released songs, most performed by DeSilva himself.
George Elia was charged with 8 additional counts relating to his alleged Ponzi scheme that he ran through International Consultants & Investment Group Limited Corp. that defrauded investors out of more than $11 million. Elia was going to enter into a plea deal as to the one count of wire fraud, but changed his mind and was then indicted on 8 additional charges. Elia targeted the Wilton Manors gay community through word of mouth marketing.
Timothy Geidel and his companies Georgetown Capital Group and Royal Alliance Associates have been sued by plaintiffs claiming that they lost more than $132,000 in “bogus securities” that Geidel sold them. Geidel pleaded guilty in 2011 to charges relating to his Ponzi scheme where he defrauded more than 40 investors of $1.3 million. Most of his investors were active or retired members of a school district and he told investors that they could make investments in certificates of deposit with 6% returns. The CDS were “fictitious and nonexistent.” He was sentenced to 3½ years in prison and ordered to make restitution.
Jon Harder, 47, of Oregon pleaded not guilty to charges that he defrauded more than 1,000 investors of $130 million, and then surrendered himself to Oregon law enforcement officials. It is alleged that Harder operated a Ponzi scheme through Sunwest Management, raising money from investors to operate more than 300 assisted-living centers. The indictment alleges that Sunwest had started to lose money in 2006, but Harder brought in more money to buy more than 100 assisted-living centers at the rate of one a week to hide the losses. The indictment seeks a money judgment of $130 million. Harder filed for personal bankruptcy protection, and in 2010, he agreed to pay $4.2 million in fines to the Oregon Division of Finance and Corporate Securities. Harder and his wife spent the misappropriated funds on a lavish lifestyle which included the acquisition of 18 pieces of property and the purchase of numerous luxury cars, including a Mercedes, a Land Rover, two BMWs, a Cadillac Escalade and a Lexus.
Yusaf Jawed and Lyman Bruhn were charged by the SEC with running a Ponzi scheme investing in blue-chip stocks, or public stocks of well-established companies. Charges were also brought against Jawed’s attorney, Robert Custis. They raised more than $37 million from more than 100 investors in the Pacific Northwest. They used false marketing materials and promised double-digit returns. Jawed controlled Griphon Asset Management, LLC, and Griphon Holdings, LLC, which served as advisers to numerous hedge funds created and managed by Jawed, including Gripfhon Alpha Fund, L.P. and Grifphon Iota Fund, L.P. Bruhn operated Pearl Investment Management LLC and Sasquatch Capital Management LLC in Portland and raised more than $600,000 from ten investors on the West Coast for a hedge fund, the Blue Chip Focus Fund. Investors were told through private placement memoranda that the funds experienced annual returns ranging from 12.8% to 132.5%. Jawed misappropriated millions of dollars in investor funds for his personal use, which included luxury vacations, lavish meals, and the payment of nearly $60,000 to settle a sexual harassment lawsuit.  
Rick Koerber of Utah saw 18 of 20 charges against him allowed to go forward in connection with allegations that he ran a $100 million Ponzi scheme. Koerber had been contesting the charges and denied that he operated his company, FranklinSquires Cos., as a Ponzi scheme. Koerber allegedly promoted “Equity Milling“ as a form of real estate investment, and advertised on billboards and magazines, and through seminars that people paid several thousands of dollars to attend.
Keith Kovac, 61, and Robert Congdon, 61, both of Montana, were sentenced to 2½ and 2 years, respectively, and must pay almost $1.2 million in restitution for their role in a Ponzi scheme operated under the name Cornerstone Financial. Kovick and Congdon illegally arranged for loans, but were not properly registered with the state.
Gary Harrison Lane, 59, a former Reno financial advisor, was indicted on charges relating to an alleged Ponzi scheme where is accused of taking at least $2.1 million from elderly and inexperienced investors. It is alleged that Lane deposited investor funds into E-trade accounts that were not affiliated with his employer, Bank of America Investment Services, while investors understood that he was purchasing U.S. Treasury Bonds on their behalf at a rate of 6%.
Philip Lester, 65, real estate broker in Nevada, was charged with securities fraud, elder abuse and conspiracy and arrested in connection with a Ponzi scheme he ran through Gold Country Lenders with his sister, Susan Laferte, 58, along with Lester’s wife, Ellen Lester, 65, who is an attorney and business partner, and their business associate Jonathan Blinder, 58. Lester would take investor funds to purportedly invest in real estate projects, but he would use the money to pay investors on other projects. He promised investors security in the form of deeds of trust owned by the entity in which the investor thought the investment was being made but, in fact no security was provided. Investors are owed more than $2.3 million.
Irwin Lipkin, 74, the former controller of Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities, was to plead guilty to charges related to falsifying documents that were provided to Madoff’s investors. The expected guilty plea was delayed after Lipkin suffered “an emergency medical condition.” Lipkin’s son, Eric S. Lipkin, pleaded guilty in 2011 to charges that he reported that people were Madoff employees so they could receive retirement benefits. It has been alleged that Lipkin continued to draw a salary from BLMIS even after retiring in 1999. Lipkin is the ninth former Madoff employee to plead guilty to criminal charges.
Steven Lippman, a lawyer who formerly worked at Ponzi schemer Scott Rothstein’s law firm, pleaded guilty to conspiring to violate federal election laws and to commit bank fraud. It is alleged that Lippman made sizable contributions to John McCain’s 2008 presidential campaign and then was illegally reimbursed by Rothstein. Additionally, it is alleged that Lippman used a bank account that he controlled to artificially inflate the value of the Rothstein firm’s accounts and fraudulently obtain additional financing. Lippman saw his pay go from $400,000 to over $1.3 million when he worked for Rothstein.
Michelle Longchamps, was given a conditional sentence for two years less a day for her role in a $1.6 million Ponzi scheme so she will not need to go to prison. Longchamps is undergoing ongoing cancer treatment which was factored into her sentencing. Longchamps used fraudulent entities such as “Integrity Financial Management.” Perhaps the license plates of her and her husband should have tipped off investors: “no job for me” and “live for free.” Her husband, Jeffrey Longchamps, received an 18 month conditional sentence in August.
Lawrence Leland Loomis, 55, of California, was indicted along with 6 others, for their role in a multistate Ponzi scheme and related mortgage fraud scams that defrauded investors of $17 million. Loomis and his father-in-law, John Hagener, 76, were charged with operating a California-based investment fund called Loomis Wealth Solutions that defrauded more than 100 investors of more than $7 million. Loomis and Hagener pleaded not guilty. Loomis was ordered held, and Hagener was freed on $1 million bond. The others charged in connection with the schemes are Darren Fehst, 44, Michael Llamas, 27, Peter Woodard, 54, Joseph A. Gekko, 43, and Dawn C. Powers, 42.
Loronda Murphy, 48, of Connecticut, pleaded guilty to charges related to a mortgage fraud Ponzi scheme in which she refinanced homes for 5 people but failed to repay the original mortgages. Murphy operated the scheme with Scott Forcino, 46, who is a real estate lawyer that oversaw some of the transactions. Murphy defrauded two banks through her company, Settle One Corporation.
James Pantazelos, 63, pleaded guilty to charges related to his operation of a Ponzi-type scheme through his company, Destiny Partners, Inc., where he took in $4,294,930 from investors and promised them 200% returns. Pantazelos told investors that their funds would be placed in “Private Investment Trading Platforms” that traded bank notes in foreign markets and that funds would be donated to charitable contributions.
Laura Pendergest-Holt, 39, the former chief investment officer of Allen Stanford’s companies, was sentenced to 3 years after she pleaded guilty to obstructing an investigation by the SEC. Pendergest-Holt gave testimony to the SEC which omitted crucial details about the finances of Stanford International Bank, Ltd., and was intended to impede the SEC’s investigation and to help the bank to continue operating.
Richard Plato 64, of Texas, was convicted by a jury in connection with a scheme run through his company, Momentum Production Corp., in which he sold promissory notes that he claimed were secured by South Texas oil and gas interests. Plato had previously been convicted of fraud in Texas, Florida and Louisiana. He sold about $6.2 million worth of notes and never disclosed his previous convictions. About $2 million of the funds were diverted to Plato’s benefit.
Grahame Rhodes of Missouri was the subject of a civil enforcement action brought by the CFTC for fraud in connection with his operations of a multi-million commodity pool Ponzi scheme. It is alleged that Rhodes took at least $2.1 million from at least 12 individuals to trade commodity futures in a pooled investment account. Rhodes was never registered with the CFTC and allegedly solicited prospective pool participants by pretending to be a successful, but cautious, trader who earned annual rates ranging between 20 and 50 percent trading E-mini S&P futures contracts.
Alan Ritter, 69, of New York, pleaded guilty to charges in connection with his 11 year operation of a $6 million Ponzi scheme. Ritter initiated the scheme in 2001 after the failure of a debt collection business he started with a partner. To cover the losses, he solicited hundreds of thousands of dollars from investors, promising to invest the funds in real estate ventures. Instead, Ritter used the funds to pay interest payments on the previous loans and to pay personal expenses.
Juan Carlos Rodriquez, 41, pleaded guilty to charges relating to his stealing $1.9 million from 63 investors and he was sentenced to 7 years in prison and ordered to pay about $2 million in restitution. Rodriquez was an accountant with an investment business, MDN Financial Group into which he lured clients, family and friends to invest, guaranteeing returns of 20 to 50 percent in each month. He was purportedly investing in stocks, bonds, and gold, but instead stole the money to pay for homes, cars and a nice lifestyle. It is alleged that Rodriguez took a total of about $5 million for 116 investors who signed investment management agreements with MDN.
Kim Rothstein, 38, Scott Rothstein’s wife, was charged in connection with allegations that she concealed more than $1 million in jewelry from federal investigators and then later attempted to sell some of it through Eddy Marin, 50, and Patrick Daoud, 54. At the time that investigators seized property from the Rothsteins’ residence, Kim Rothstein assured them that they had everything, but it is alleged that she and two others “knowingly took action to conceal certain items of jewelry.” It is also alleged that Kim Rothstein and her co-conspirators, Stacie Weisman, 49, and Scott F. Saidel, 45, tried to persuade Scott Rothstein to testify falsely about the location of jewelry. Kim has plead not guilty to the charges, but it is expected that she will enter into a plea agreement with prosecutors. Marin has been charged with obstruction of justice and perjury.
Francis X. Sanchez, 52, was sentenced to more than 11 years in prison and ordered to pay more than $7.8 million in restitution for his role in a $7.2 million Ponzi scheme operated through InvestForForeclosures with his partner, James D. Bourassa, 55. Sanchez represented that he bought distressed houses, rehabilitated them, and sold them for profit. He pleaded guilty to fraud in May and admitted in his plea agreement that that he solicited people to invest in InvestForClosures by making various misrepresentations, including: (1) that their investments would be safe because they would be backed by real estate; (2) that InvestForClosures used the majority of its investors’ funds to purchase real estate; and (3) that because of the business’s efficient cash flow from buying and selling houses, InvestForClosures had never failed to make an interest payment on time or to return an investor’s principal when requested. Sanchez also represented that he was developing an exclusive residential community in Mexico known as The Sands of Gold. Bourassa was sentenced to 51 months in prison.
Eric Schmickle, 37, and his company Q Wealth Management Inc. were charged by the CFTC in connection with allegations that they were operating a commodity futures Ponzi scheme that took in at least $5.3 million from at least 10 customers. It is alleged that Schmickle made misrepresentations to induce investments and then created and sent false account statements. Scmickle has already pleaded guilty in a related criminal action.
Feisal Sharif, 42, of Connecticut has been charged, arrested, and released on $150,000 bail, in connection with operating a Ponzi scheme through his company, First Financial LLC, that defrauded investors of hundreds of thousands of dollars. It is alleged that Sharif created and emailed bogus account statements to convince the victim that his $400,000 investment had appreciated to more than $2.2 million and that the funds were secure.
Joseph Angelo Sivigliano, 80, was sentenced to 8 years in prison and ordered to pay more than $2.21 million in restitution for his role in $3.8 million Ponzi scheme in which he sold “investment opportunities” in Helping Hearts and Hands Inc. (HHH) based in Oklahoma. Sivigliano took in $3.8 million from 67 investors and paid some of that money out to earlier investors and some to his businesses Celebrity Limo Valet Corp., MC Productions Inc., and Lansbrook Worship & Event Center. He held out as a charitable organization that benefits philanthropic ventures such as a Christian childcare facility called “Teaching Little Hearts and Hands.” Co-conspirator Dwight Pimson, 57, of Louisiana, and Marie Pimson, 43, or Oklahoma, pleaded guilty and were sentenced to 5 years and 30 months, respectively, and were ordered to pay restitution of more than $2.7 million each.
Michael Turnock, 68, and William P. Sullivan II, of Colorado, were unsuccessful in their attempt to be relieved from a freeze order of their assets obtained by the SEC in connection with allegations that they operated a $15.7 million Ponzi scheme through Bridge Premium Finance LLC. They had sought a release of their assets on the basis that they are suffering economic hardship and health issues.
Hugo Edgardo Urrea, 55, a youth baseball coach, pleaded guilty to charges in connection with a Ponzi scheme that defrauded about two dozen victims of $419,000. Urea promised that he would invest the money or provide investment advice, but instead kept the money to use it to pay his mortgage and his son’s university tuition. Urrea was sentenced to 20 years, with 15 of those years suspended, and ordered to pay $247,000 in restitution.
Doug Vaughan, 64, who pleaded guilty to charges relating to his Ponzi scheme in December 2011, was sentenced to 12 years in prison in connection with his Ponzi scheme that stole $75 million from more than 600 investors. Vaughan then filed a Chapter 7 bankruptcy petition. Vaughan ran his scheme through his New Mexico residential brokerage firm called Vaughan Company Realtors. Vaughan had spent investor funds on his “Ponzi Palace,” which was a four bedroom, seven bath mansion with a poolside cabana and wine cellar on a golf course, along with almost $800,000 for luxuries including $252,653.38 for domestic and international travel, $146,263.64 on clothes and jewelry, $153,710.58 on home furnishings. Vaughan’s bookkeeper, Martha Runkle, was sentenced as well, but the terms of her sentencing agreement have been sealed.
Spero Vourliotis, 52, of Alabama, pleaded guilty to and agreed to repay $5.3 million as restitution in connection with his Ponzi scheme-like operation which he ran through Capston Group, Cornerstone Investment Group and Tristone Investment Group. Vourliotis took in about $7.5 million from about 36 investors in these investment clubs. Carey Michael Billingsley also pleaded guilty today to one count of selling an unregistered security in the scheme. Billingsley was an associate with Vourliotis who recruited some investors.
Michael Winans Jr. has waived his right to be indicted by a grand jury and was charged in connection with charges that he operated a Ponzi scheme in which he represented that the Winans Foundation Trust was investing in crude oil bonds in Saudi Arabia. Winans is the son of Michael Winans Sr., a member of the Gospel Hall of Fame quartet the Winans. He is alleged to have taken at least $8 million from 1,000 victims, guaranteeing the victims that the bonds would yield returns of $1,000 to $8,000 within 60 days.
William J. Wise, 62, pleaded guilty to counts in connection with his $130 million Ponzi scheme run through Millennium Bank, its Geneva-based parent United Trust of Switzerland S.A. and Sterling Bank and Trust, all of which were all controlled by Wise. The scheme defrauded about 1,200 investors by selling them bogus certificates of deposit.
Troy B. Wragg, Amanda E. Knorr, Speed of Wealth, LLC, Wayde M. McKelvy, Donna McKelvy, and Mantria Corporation, had a final judgment entered against them, ordering them to disgorge millions of dollars in connection with a scheme that raised funds for Mantria “green” initiatives such as “carbon negative” housing community and “biochar” charcoal substitute made from organic waste. Investors were promised returns from 17 percent to “hundreds of percent” annually.

INTERNATIONAL PONZI SCHEME NEWS
Australia
David Hobbs was hit with a reserved judgment in connection with an alleged $50 million Ponzi scheme involving 14 unlicensed investment funds. Hobbs is one of 19 defendants originally named in a lawsuit brought by the Australian Securities and Investment Commission. Hobbs, though Vanuatu company, Future Trading Corporation Ltd., took in more than $42 million (NZ$50 million) from more than 700 Australians where investors were promised access to offshore investment opportunities and the wholesale financial market generating returns of about 3 to 4 percent or more per month with no risk of losing the invested money.
Canada
Milowe Brost and Gary Sorenson were ordered to pay millions in penalties by the Alberta Securities Commission in connection with a Ponzi scheme in which it is alleged that 4,000 investors were bilked out of at least $100 million. The Alberta Securities Commission has imposed sanctions about $54 million against Brost and Sorenson, along with Dennis Morice, the Institute for Financial Learning, Group of Companies Inc. and Merendon Mining Corporation Ltd.
Gerald Berke lost his bid to have his extradition case in Canada thrown out. Berke is wanted by the FBI in connection with a Ponzi scheme that he operated in California that defrauded about 70 investors out of $81 million.
England
David Bowerman, 35, pleaded guilty to 33 fraud charges relating to a Ponzi scheme in which he took up to £5 million from about 200 investors. Bowerman was a mortgage advisor and defrauded 200 investors, including his own mother.
Nicholas Levene, 48, has admitted to running a £32m Ponzi scheme. Known as “Beano,” Levene promised investors he was buying shares, but in fact stole some of the money. Levene would falsify documents to make it look like he had bought them shares or made them profits when in fact they were being stolen from. His victims allegedly include property developers the Tchenguiz brothers, music mogul Simon Cowell and Sir Philip Green.
India
A group of investors in Shams Investment has sued Abdul Mubin Shaikh, Imran Qazi Painter, Feroz Ali Najmushani, and Shakun Patel in connection with an investment scheme run through Shams Investment and its two subsidiaries, Akshar Colour Limited and Green Nest Infratech Ltd. Investors were promised 10% returns every month on their principal and were promised that they could win a flat in the real estate project of the company if they took part in a monthly lucky draw. About 50 investors who had lost their money in the scheme sat on a one-day fast to draw the attention of the police. The alleged perpetrators have not yet been charged and many cannot presently be located.
Ireland
An international bench warrant was issued for Francois de Dietrich in connection with an alleged scam he ran from Etic Solutions. De Dietrich has previously been convicted of fraud and served a two-year jail term in France. Now it is alleged that 187 investors have been defrauded in connection with a scheme where he told investors they could make large returns when he used their money to buy second-hand planes, Rolls Royces and other big ticket items at auctions and then sell them to Middle East investors. De Dietrich has been on the run, and he was sentenced to 18 months in prison in his absence after refusing to reveal information about his worldwide assets.
The investment firm of Custom House Capital collapsed after being run like a Ponzi scheme which promised prominent investors attractive returns. More than 1,500 investors invested as much as €500m.
Majorca
John Hirst, 61, Richard Pollett, 70, and Linda Hirst, 62, were sentenced in connection with their £10 million Ponzi scheme. Hirst was sentenced to nine years in prison for his role in the Ponzi scheme that targeted ex-pats in Mallorca. Financial advisor Pollett was sentenced for six and a half years. Linda Hirst was sentenced to two and a half years. John Hirst and Pollett promised investors returns of 20 % per annum. Of the £10 million of investor deposits, less than £5 million was paid out to investors to give the impression the scheme was working. The rest of the money was used to fund Hirst’s extravagant lifestyle which included spending £90,000 on his Las Vegas wedding and at least £270,000 spent renovating Hirst’s villa in Mallorca.  Additionally, approximately £160,000 was spent on hotels, holidays, and flights with more than £25,000 spent on jewelry.
New Zealand
Jacqui Bradley, who ran a Ponzi scheme with her late husband, Mike, though B’On Financial Services, was found guilty. Bradley owed more than $15 million to 28 investors.
Russia
Sergei Mavrodi, the creator of the 1990s MMM Ponzi scheme, has created a political party with the same name. The goal of this new party is supposedly to bring about “world financial apocalypse.” Mavrodi served 4½ years for his scheme that defrauded 10 to 15 million Russians of $110 million.

NEWSWORTHY LEGAL ISSUES IN PENDING PONZI SCHEME CASES
Singer John Mayer has been sued for $465,000 by the trustee administering the Darren Berg $100 million Ponzi scheme. Berg had paid a booking agency Grabow & Associates the funds and Mayer was paid by Grabow for his appearance at a corporate event in 2008. Berg was sentenced to 18 months for his role in the Ponzi scheme.
Investors who lost more than $2.5 million in the Ponzi scheme of Blue Mountain Consumer Discount Co. have served a subpoena on the FBI for documents that the FBI seized from the home and offices of Francis Cinelli in connection with a lawsuit against Cinelli and the CEO of the company, Walter “Buddy” Lambert. The FBI seized about 20 boxes of documents in 2011, and the investors need the documents to move their civil case forward. The FBI said it had copied about half of the items. The court overseeing the manner suggested that the victims serve a subpoena to force the FBI to release the documents.
The trustee of the Ponzi scheme of Dante DeMiro in Michigan has obtained the voluntary turnover of funds from various entities. He received the return of $22,500 from the city of Muskegon Heights, $500,000 from Comstock Township, a Kalamazoo area township, and nearly $1.5 million from other entities.
Irving Picard, the trustee of the Bernard L. Madoff Ponzi scheme case, made a distribution of about $2.5 billion to victims, which is the second pro rata distribution he has made. The victims have previously received disbursements from Picard and they have received advances from the Securities Investor Protection Corporation, which brings the amounts paid to victims for their losses to over 50%.
Nigel Fielding, the CEO of HSBC (Luxembourg), is being sued in the Cayman Islands for breach of duty, willful neglect and willful default in his capacity as a director of Primeo Fund, whose entire assets of more than $786 million were invested in Bernard Madoff’s fraudulent enterprise.
Investors and the receiver in the Ponzi scheme case of Management Solutions, Inc. are battling over disclosure of records and the receiver’s proposed auction of the remaining assets. The investors want the receiver to turnover over marketing reports and property appraisals relating to property that the receiver might include in the auction, and the receiver has expressed concern over how much input the investors should have in the running of the receivership. The receiver hopes that one big auction will reduce the ongoing costs of the receivership. Management Solutions took in over $200 million from investors in operating one of the largest ever Utah Ponzi schemes.
The former finance’ of Thomas Petters, Tracy Mixon, 39, saw her support payments end this month. Mixon had been receiving support payments for her and her two children with Petters for many years. The receiver of the Petters case filed a motion to stop the support payments, noting that Mixon has had “ample time” to find a job or make other arrangements to support her family.
The Trustee in the Scott Rothstein bankruptcy case has settled with the Razorback investors in which it is proposed that the Razorback group would be allowed a special payment of $8 million as a “substantial contribution” claim because of the resources expended by the Razorback group in pursuing TD Bank and others in court. The Razorback investors alleged that they lost about $200 million in the Rothstein Ponzi scheme. They have already reached a settlement with TD bank for $170 million and a smaller settlement with Gibraltar Private Bank and Trust.
TD Bank settled a lawsuit brought by Emess Capital, which had sued for $33.8 million in connection with the Scott Rothstein Ponzi scheme case. Emess had amended its complaint to allege that the bank had violated the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO), which permits victims of racketeering to recover treble damages. The terms of the settlement are confidential. The lawsuits against TD have alleged that it aided Rothstein’s $1.2 billion Ponzi scheme by ignoring fraud alerts and by issuing phony “lock letters” to Rothstein’s victims that promised their money was only to be released to them. A former TD executive allegedly signed the letters.
SPD Group, operating as J.R. Dunn Jewelers, agreed to a $325,000 settlement with the trustee administering the Ponzi scheme case of Scott Rothstein’s law firm, Rothstein Rosenfeldt Alder. Rothstein reportedly bought more than $2 million in jewelry from J.R. Dunn between November 2005 and October 2009, including many items for Rothstein’s wife, Kim.
TD Bank’s motion for a new trial in the case in connection with the Scott Rothstein case, where it was hit with a $67 million jury verdict in favor of Coquina Investments, was denied. The court found, “The jury was entitled to find… that it was particularly reprehensible...that a bank, which people entrust with their money, would aid and abet a Ponzi scheme such as the one Rothstein was operating.”
A claim for negligence against the SEC by investors in the Stanford Financial Ponzi scheme withstood a motion to dismiss. The claim is that, despite knowledge of the Ponzi scheme as early as 1997, the SEC failed to notify the Securities Investor Protection Corp. The lawsuit alleges that the SEC has a nondiscretionary obligation to report a broker/dealer to SIPC when the SEC believes that the broker or dealer is in or approaching financial difficulty.
The liquidators in the Allen Stanford case have filed a lawsuit against Canadian TD Bank, alleging collusion in the Stanford Ponzi scheme. The complaint alleges, “But for TD Bank’s conduct… the [fraud] would have been discovered and prevented, the fraudulent transactions… would not have been completed and damages would not have been suffered by SIB and its customers.” Although the complaint alleges $20 million in damages, the plaintiffs have said that their claims may exceed $3 billion. TD Bank has filed a motion to dismiss the complaint.
Greenwich Insurance Co. has filed a lawsuit claiming that it has no duty to defend or indemnify Dallas law firm Carter Holmes PLLC or Steve Holmes in connection with lawsuits that have sprung from the $57 million Striker Petroleum Ponzi scheme. Greenwich contends that the defendant have no coverage because the claims were not made and reported during any single policy period. The allegations of the Ponzi scheme which was revealed in 2009 were that Striker, Mark Roberts, 58, and Christopher Pippin, 35, had defrauded investors of $57 million, promising debentures collateralized by oil and gas properties.
Dustin Diamond, who played the character Screech on “Saved by the Bell,” has been sued by the receiver of the estate of Robert Stinson. Stinson is serving 33 years in prison for his Ponzi scheme operated through his company, Life’s Good, Inc., that defrauded 263 investors of more than $17 million. Diamond was named in the complaint along with Rogue International Talent Group dba Rogue Entertainment dba Rogue Talent Agency; Roger Paul Inc.; Roger Paul; High Idea Corp. dba High Ideas Inc. who had received money out of the Ponzi scheme, some of which had been lent to Diamond and has not yet been repaid.
The receiver of the estate of Ronnie Wilson and his company, Atlantic Bullion and Coin, Inc., was authorized to sell silver bars that were seized by authorities and to use the proceeds for an eventual distribution to defrauded investors. The silver bars were sold for $675,000. Wilson pleaded guilty to charges in connection with his $90 million Ponzi scheme.
The state of California has sued movie producers Windsor Pictures, Skyline Pictures, Michelle Kenen Seward, Dror Soref, and others, alleging that they were operating a Ponzi scheme and committing fraud in raising more than $23 million to supposedly make and distribute movies. The victims were mostly seniors who were invited to seminars and were offered a “no risk” investment in movies that would have “high rates of return.” The complaint alleges that Seward told prospective investors that she was tired of seeing seniors being taken advantage of by the financial industry” and that this was not a Ponzi scheme. The complaint also names Protege Financial & Insurance Service dba Senior Retirement Specialists and Teacher Retirement Specialists, Saxe-Coburg Insurance Solutions LLC, Not Forgotten LLC, and Scott Walter Foulk.
More than 33,000 customers of Zeek Rewards have signed a petition to keep the company in operation, standing behind the company and contesting the receiver’s appointment and administration of the company. The petition states that the shutdown of Zeek has “devastated them and that they are “behind Zeek Rewards, Zeekler, Rex Venture, and Paul Burks one hundred percent.” Once of the individuals leading this group, Robert Craddock, who has been openly critical of the SEC for shutting down the business, has been subpoenaed by the SEC. A lawyer for Fun Club USA, Inc., a company owned by Craddock, has filed a motion for permission to appear in the Zeek case. The receiver has so far recovered almost $300 million in assets but is still looking for more. It is estimated that this was a $600 million Ponzi scheme that involved approximately 1 million investors. Burks has agreed to pay $4 million in a penalty and give up his interest in the firm without admitting or denying guilt.

Saturday, September 15, 2012

Federal Equity Receivers Gathered at NAFER Annual Conference

Posted by Kathy Bazoian Phelps
The inaugural conference of the National Association of Federal Equity Receivers just concluded in Fort Worth, Texas and was a fantastic gathering of close to 60 federal equity receivers and other professionals. The caliber of educational programs and professionals in attendance was exceptional. I particularly enjoyed meeting many of the receivers whose cases are cited in The Ponzi Book: A Legal Resource for Unraveling Ponzi Schemes. The panels included discussions on the pros and cons of bankruptcy versus receivership, parallel civil insolvency proceedings and forfeiture proceedings, tax issues arising in receiverships, recovery of assets overseas, and first day issues in a receivership. 
I spoke on two panels which drew a lot of audience participation and discussion of different experiences and methodologies used by different receivers:

     Bankruptcy vs. Receivership: Different Strokes for Different Folks
     
     Forfeited Assets: Yours, Mine or Ours:  Competition in Parallel Civil and Criminal Proceedings

NAFER has attracted the attention of the players in this field and will be a great organization going forward for educational content for federal equity receivers and a forum for networking and sharing ideas of what does and doesn’t work in these types of receivership cases.  The NAFER website is www.naferforum.org if you want to learn more about the organization.

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Finger-Pointing at the SEC: Whose Fault Is It That Ponzi Schemes Thrive?

Posted by Kathy Bazoian Phelps

When a Ponzi scheme crash lands, all kinds of things go flying. The dollars go into the wind, the tangible assets go underground, the perpetrator is thrown into jail, and the allegations of wrongdoing are strewn about with a vengeance.

The defrauded investors, and society at large, should of course be the most upset with the perpetrator himself or herself. But that person is usually already sitting in jail, sometimes even for what is the balance of their lives as is the case with Bernie Madoff and Allen Stanford. Retribution is one of the more minor of the objectives of the criminal justice system; however, it is a significant element of a defrauded investor’s mental state in trying to reconstruct what went wrong and who to blame. A defrauded investor left in financial ruin must live day-to-day with the loss caused by the jailed perpetrator. Story after story of the country club nature of some of the prisons in which these perpetrators now reside merely serves to inflame an already financially devastated life.

Defrauded investors, therefore, quite understandably want more accountability from someone. They can’t get any more out of the perpetrator sitting in jail. So they look to our protectors and ask why the government gatekeepers did not stop the fraud. The government allocates sizeable portions of the federal budget to run governmental agencies designed to protect us from fraud. The SEC is, of course, the most visible of such organizations and the one that we most count on to protect our interests and to stop fraud in its tracks. Unfortunately, there has not been much fraud-stopping in the higher profile cases of late.

Investors have tried and failed to hold the SEC liable for failing to detect the Madoff fraud. See, e.g., Donahue v. United States, 2012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 84353 (D.C. June 19, 2012). Now, in the Ponzi scheme case of R. Allen Stanford, some investors are seeking to hold the SEC liable for negligence in not stopping the Stanford Ponzi scheme. The plaintiffs in Zelaya v. United States, 2012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 127233(S.D. Fla. Sept. 7, 2012), have sued the SEC for negligence for failing to follow two statutory obligations which they allege were nondiscretionary. If the duties were nondiscretionary, then the SEC would be unable to assert sovereign immunity to shield itself from liability. 

First, the plaintiffs alleged that the SEC knew as early as 1997 that Stanford was operating a Ponzi scheme, yet failed to comply with the nondiscretionary obligation to report that fact to SPIC. Second, the plaintiffs allege that the SEC did not review the investment advisor’s registration amendments and did not deny the annual registration after the SEC had allegedly concluded that Stanford was operating as a Ponzi scheme. 

The court denied in part and granted in part the SEC’s motion to dismiss the negligence claims against it. The court concluded:
While the determination of whether a broker/dealer is in or approaching financial difficulty is inherently discretionary, once the Securities and Exchange Commission concludes that a broker/dealer is in or approaching financial difficulty a nondiscretionary duty to report this information to the Securities Investor Protection Corporation arises. However, the Securities and Exchange Commission's treatment of an investment advisor's amendment to its Section 80b-3 registration application involves an element of judgment grounded in policy considerations, and thus falls under the discretionary function exception of the FTCA.

So it remains to be seen whether these investors will succeed in holding the SEC liable for their losses. On the one remaining claim, they will need to show that the SEC knew that Stanford was operating a Ponzi scheme, which may still present a big hurdle for the investors.

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Equitable Subordination of Claims in Ponzi Scheme Cases – Gray Standards With Black and White Consequences

Posted by Kathy Bazoian Phelps
The tool of equitable subordination in a Ponzi scheme case can have a significant impact on the ultimate distributions in the case. Whether used by a trustee seeking to subordinate a claim, or challenged by a creditor seeking to hold on to the priority of its claim, § 510(c) of the Bankruptcy Code can cause significant swings in the manner in which claims are ultimately allowed and paid in a Ponzi scheme case.
The standards for equitable subordinate were best defined in In re Mobile Steel Co., 563 F.2d 692, 700 (5th Cir. 1977), which stated in part that a court can equitably subordinate a claim when the claimant has “engaged in some type of inequitable conduct” and the “misconduct must have resulted in injury to the creditors of the bankrupt or conferred an unfair advantage on the claimant.”
In the past year, we have seen some high profile decisions and discussion on the topic, which leave room for questioning exactly what standard is applied. In the Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme case, the trustee sought to have the claims of Saul B. Katz and related defendants subordinated based on allegations that the defendants did not receive fraudulent transfers in good faith and that they had engaged in inequitable conduct. Picard v. Katz, 462 B.R. 447 (S.D.N.Y. 2011). The court declined to dismiss the complaint, finding that, “this alleged misconduct would have injured any investors who invested in Madoff Securities based on the impressive returns others appeared to receive.” In other words, a trustee in a Ponzi scheme could subordinate claims of investors by proving that they acted “with knowledge, or in reckless disregard” of the fraud. This could be a powerful tool for trustees to reprioritize claims and bump certain investor claims ahead of others.
On the other hand, just last month, the Seventh Circuit held that equitable subordination of a bank’s claim was inappropriate because “gross and egregious misconduct” had not been demonstrated. In re Sentinel Management Group, Inc., 2012 U.S. App. LEXIS 16546 (7th Cir. Aug. 9, 2012). In that case, the debtor was supposed to maintain customer assets in segregated accounts, but instead had pledged hundreds of millions of dollars in customer assets to secure a loan from the Bank of New York. The trustee sued the bank, alleging that the bank knew that that debtor had fraudulently used customer assets to finance the loan and that the bank acted inequitably and unlawfully.
The Sentinel court held that equitable subordination of the bank’s claim was inappropriate because the bank was negligent, not fraudulent. The court noted, “Perhaps the bank should have known that [the debtor had] violated segregation requirements, but as the district court found, ‘such a lack of care does not rise to the level of the egregious misconduct necessary for equitable subordination.’”
The Sentinel court was quite critical of the bank officials, calling them “such artless liars that they couldn’t have been concealing deliberate wrongdoing. Instead, the bank officials were simply trying to cover up their own incompetence . . . . And incompetence alone, however problematic, won't require the equitable subordination of the bank’s lien.”
The juxtaposition of these two cases leaves the standard for equitable subordination confused. In one case, Picard v. Katz, equitable subordination is a possibility where there is an investor accused of not accepting transfers in good faith and allegations that other investors might have invested based on the impressive returns paid to the defendant investor.
     Picard v. Katz Score Card
          Inequitable conduct – Yes
          Harm to other creditors – Maybe
          Equitable Subordination – Yes
In the other case, In re Sentinel Management, the bank is alleged to have known about the fraud, but the court merely found it incompetent. Rather than speculating that others might be damaged, many investors were actually damaged when the bank accepted the investors’ supposedly segregated funds as collateral for a loan. Equitable subordination was not allowed in Sentinel despite the actual harm to the investors.
     Sentinel Score Card
          Inequitable conduct (defined as “egregious conduct”) – No
          Harm to other creditors – Yes
          Equitable Subordination – No
These cases demonstrate that some form of inequitable conduct makes all the difference. But what is “inequitable conduct”? Sentinel says that “gross incompetence” - sufficient to cause a district court judge to call you an “artless liar” - is not inequitable conduct. However, the Sentinel court appears to have morphed the "inequitable conduct" test of Mobile Steel into an “egregious misconduct” test. The Katz court, on the other hand, was more focused on some form of wrongful conduct which harmed other creditors or conferred an unfair advantage on the claimant.
The question that is left open after these two cases is whether the “inequitable conduct” test of Mobile Steele was intended to cover any wrongful conduct, even negligence, for the purpose of protecting creditors whose conduct was wholly innocent. In any event, an equitable subordination claim is by definition an equitable claim that should not be subject to rigorous "elements," but rather a weighing of all of the circumstances. However, while the standard is a bit gray, the consequences can be black and white on the issue of whether a particular creditor will receive any payment in a Ponzi case.

Friday, August 31, 2012

August 2012 Ponzi Scheme Roundup

Posted by Kathy Bazoian Phelps
The Ponzi scheme news for the month of August is as vibrant as ever. Here are brief summaries of many of the stories that have been reported. I’ve included some international stories as well that made the news. Please feel free to post comments about other Ponzi schemes that I may have missed. And please remember that I am just relaying what’s in the news, not writing it.
Kevin Ray Asbury of Missouri has been sentenced to 9 years in federal prison in connection with two cattle fraud schemes that involved approximately $8 million of investor funds. Asbury pleaded guilty to charges relating to his Ponzi-type operation involving R&K Angus Ranch. He used investors' money to cover his own expenses and to pay purported returns to earlier investors. He also obtained a $4 million line of credit from a bank by pledging as collateral thousands of cattle he did not own.
George Atwater, a former corporate lawyer, pleaded guilty in connection with charges that he helped defraud an investor of $10 million by forging bank documents. At the time, Atwater was working for Robert Miracle, who is now serving 13 years in federal prison for running the elaborate Ponzi scheme. Miracle solicited investors by telling them he made money by operating companies supposedly involved in oil development in Malaysia and Indonesia. Miracle paid out about $37 million to some investors and lenders. The remainder was used in part to develop oil and gas fields in Indonesia and to pay for his lavish lifestyle. Atwater forged bank documents to convince an investor that the company was making money in oil and gas fields, showing fake deposits and bogus payments for drilling expenses. The statements were used to mislead the investor and induced the investor to invest $10 million.
Bitcoin Savings & Trust, an invite-only online hedge fund that promised large returns, has gone off-line. The service’s administrator, known as pirateat40, claimed it had collected 500,000 worth of Bitcoin currency, worth about $5.49 million. Although payouts were promised, no such payment has been made, and pirateat40 seems to have disappeared from the Web.
Thomas Bowdoin, 77, of Florida, the founder of AdSurf Inc., pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 78 months in prison in connection with his $120 million Ponzi scheme which promised investors 125% on their investments.
Ivan Wade Brown, 45, of Utah, was charged by the SEC with operating a real estate Ponzi scheme through his companies Avanti Capital Partners, LLC and Highland Residential, LLC, that may have taken in up to $27 million from investors. The SEC requested an asset freeze and the appointment of a receiver. The scheme was to provide “bridge loans” to homebuilders. The investors were provided promissory notes and were told their investments were nearly risk-free, with a worst case scenario of a 10% loss of principal. Ironically, Brown invested much of his investors’ funds in other Ponzi schemes. In addition to the bad investments, Brown spent money on the purchase of a luxury home in Alpine, Utah, a $120,000 down payment on his residence, a $225,000 airplane, and $650,000 towards the production of a motion picture.
James Scott Brown, 67, of Leawood, Kansas, was sentenced to 3 years in federal prison and ordered to pay more than $34 million in restitution, after pleading guilty to charges relating to a $52 million Ponzi scheme involving approximately 140 investors. His co-conspirator, Martin Sigillito, 63, an ordained bishop and attorney, was convicted and is awaiting sentencing, and his other co-conspirator, Derek J. Smith, 68, pleaded guilty and is awaiting sentencing. Brown and Sigillito lured investors into their program called the British Lending Program (BLP), promising returns of 17.5% to 25% for a one year loan made to BLP. They spent the investors’ money on themselves by paying Brown nearly $1.5 million and Sigillito approximately $6 million in management fees. Sigillito was chauffeured around town and purchased expensive antiques, including a $120,000 German book from the 15th century, Persian rugs, and British jewelry.
William Crafton of San Diego, California, has been sued, along with SunTrust Bank, Martin Kelly Capital Management and CSI Capital Management, for activities in relation to alleged Ponzi and other fraudulent schemes. Three NFL veterans, Joshua Feeley, Brent Celek and Kevin Curtis, and a woman pro soccer player, Heather Mitts, have filed a lawsuit alleging that they lost their investment accounts that they placed with Crafton as their financial advisor. Crafton is accused of having represented that he was investing their funds in conservative low risk investments, yet he allegedly invested their funds in Ponzi schemes or other fraudulent investments run, managed, controlled, operated and/or created by individuals with whom Crafton had a personal relationship, business dealings, or kickback agreements.
Brian Ray Dining, 47, was arrested in Virginia in connection with a $2.5 million Ponzi scheme he was operating in South Africa. Dining describes himself as an international tax lawyer with an interest in Africa and charity work. He represented that he was working on an “innovative sustainable resources and development model for use in developing countries around the world and especially in Africa.” Dining took money from investors supposedly for projects in South Africa, including a hotel, housing development, gold and diamond mines, charities and wildlife reserves. Dining is accused of misappropriating investor funds to pay for a $975,000 house, alimony, and his children’s private school tuition.
Jim Donnan, 67, a Hall of Fame football coach who coached the University of Georgia and Marshall University, has been sued by the SEC in connection with charges that he helped run a Ponzi scheme that defrauded former players and fellow coaches, promising investors annual rates of return ranging from 50% to 380%. Donnan is accused of raising $80 million from about 100 investors with his partner, Gregory Crabtree, 50, through their West Virginia-based business, GLC Ltd., which supposedly bought, liquidated, damaged and returned merchandise from major retailers for resale to discounters. The SEC alleges that only $12 million of the $80 million was actually used to buy merchandise, much of which was sitting unsold in warehouses. Donnan is accused of taking $7.4 million for himself. Donnan has filed for personal bankruptcy.
Charles David Eizelman, 68, pleaded guilty to operating a Ponzi scheme that targeted senior citizens. Eizelman advised investors that he would place their funds in legitimate investments and have interest payments sent to them. Instead, he took the money for himself. Eizelman agreed to pay $387,100 in restitution to the victims, with $100,000 to be paid at the sentencing.
Jim Ellis was appointed a federal public defender after being notified that he was the target of a criminal investigation. Ellis, in concert with his daughter Janis Ellis and alleged co-conspirator George Elia, have been accused by victims of vouching for the success of George Elia, a day trader who operated a Ponzi scheme. The Ellis’s acted as satisfied investors, and Jim Ellis provided personal guarantees in connection with promised returns of 20%.
Ulrich Felix Anton Engler aka Joseph Miller, 51, from Germany, was arrested by U.S. immigration authorities after a fingerprint match from a DUI stop in Las Vegas matched fingerprints from German authorities. Engler is accused of masterminding a $100 million Ponzi scheme in 2003 and 2004 using his company Private Commercial Office ("PCO") to solicit investments from investors worldwide. Engler sought investments for his day trading of securities, and represented that he had a powerful trading software that could analyze approximately 5,000 stock trades per second, which therefore enabled Engler to capture profits before other similarly situated traders. Engler’s bankruptcy trustee, Robert Tardif, Jr., sought court approval to take the 2004 examination of Engler before his deportation, which request was granted.
The Entrust Group Inc., Entrust Administration Inc., Entrust New Direction IRA Inc. nka New Direction IRA Inc., Entrust Arizona LLC nka Vantage Retirement Plans LLC, and Equity Trust Co have been sued in connection with an IRA-based Ponzi scheme. The class action accuses the defendants as follows: "Equity Trust and Entrust have made hundreds of millions of dollars while claiming to 'administer' SDIRAs that have resulted in many of their customers losing their entire live savings (which were invested in SDIRA 'investments' that were illegal, illusory, nonexistent, or failing)." The complaint further alleges: "The fraud promoters invested the money deposited by plaintiffs and class members in their SDIRAs in 'investments' that were fraudulent, illusory, or nonexistent. The custodians aided and abetted the fraud by periodically sending out investment account statements showing extraordinary investment returns in the SDIRAs when in fact the fraud promoters were absconding with the victims' money."
Ibis Febles, 66, of New York, was sentenced after pleading guilty to operating a scheme that took funds from Latino investors purportedly to invest in a company that bought and sold real estate for an above-market return of 10% to 14%. Febles worked with Giancarlo Giuseppe, 69, who cannot presently be located, in operating the scheme under Buyersnet Real Estate. Victims were given a “Guaranteed Interest Options” certificate that entitled them to the high returns in exchange for their investment, but the victims’ funds were not used for real estate.
Joseph Greenblatt, 50, of New York, rejected a plea deal of 6 to 18 years and $31 million in restitution, in connection with an alleged $42 million Ponzi scheme run through his real estate investment firm, Maywood Capital. His two co-defendants, lawyer Peter Vogel, and former Elmwood Park Council President Joseph Mongelli, have pleaded guilty. The complication in Greenblatt's plea deal is apparently whether he would serve the sentence concurrently with two prior sentences on fraud charges that he is currently serving.
In relation to the Ponzi scheme of Jose Nino de Guzman, lawsuits have been filed by 14 investors against the Seattle law firm of Graham & Dunn, which provided legal advice to Guzman. It has been alleged that Graham & Dunn was conspiring with Guzman to conceal a big secret. Graham & Dunn contends that it urged Guzman file Regulation D forms after the sale of securities and to comply with securities laws. A separate lawsuit has also been filed by one of Guzman’s investors against U.S. Bank, accusing the bank of turning a blind eye to Guzman’s alleged crimes.
Michael Justin Hoopes of Rexburg Idaho has been ordered to pay more than $10.4 million in restitution and a civil penalty of over $1.4 million for operating a Ponzi scheme that defrauded Idaho residents and others. Hoopes allegedly fraudulently solicited and accepted $2,068,103 from ten individuals, mostly Idaho residents, to trade stock index commodity futures in a commodity pool that he owned and operated called Aspen Trading, LLC. Hoopes also solicited an additional $9.68 million from other mostly Idaho residents during the same period for various other investments. Hoopes told some investors that they would earn 20 percent annually on their investments, that he was earning annual returns well in excess of 25 to 30 percent and that he had not lost any money in trading.
Michael Anthony Jenkins, 56, was charged in connection with his $100,000 Ponzi scheme run through his company, Harbor Light Asset Management LLC. Jenkins told investors that he was trading E Mini Futures. He was not registered to sell securities.
David Lincoln Johnson, 73, was sentenced to 30 months in prison for filing two false tax returns which failed to disclose a personal bank account in Costa Rica. Johnson has already been sentenced to 14 years in prison for his role in a Southern California Ponzi scheme operated under the name the Genesis Fund. Johnson used the Costa Rica bank account to conceal Genesis Fund distributions from the IRS. Johnson was ordered to pay restitution of $2.3 million - about $1.9 million to investors in the Genesis Fund and $400,000 to the IRS. The Genesis Fund had operated a Ponzi scheme that collected about $20 million from hundreds of investors.
George and Teresa Kastanes, 62 and 54, have been accused of misappropriating more than $10 million from loan proceeds obtained from the Detroit Police and Fire Retirement in connection with an alleged Ponzi scheme they ran through their company, Paramount Land Holdings. The Kastanes’ borrowed $10 million from the pension system ostensibly for the purposes of investing in distressed properties for resale; however, it is alleged that they fled to the Caribbean and spent large sums on jeweled Russian eggs and statues by French sculptor Auguste Rodin. The Kastanes’ allegedly owe the pension system and other creditors at least $39.5 million. The couple’s business partner, Abner McWhorter, committed suicide after a lawsuit was initiated by the pension fund.
Stephen J. Klos, 86, of Washington, pleaded guilty to securities fraud in connection with a $3.5 million Ponzi scheme in which he met victims at his church, Mercer Island Covenant Church, and told them he would invest their money. Klos had been asked by the church to stop soliciting members, many of which were elderly victims, and was eventually asked to leave the church.
Tomas Loebel, 57, is already serving 15 years in prison for his $1 million Ponzi scheme he operated through a company called The Rose Garden. Loebel has been sentenced to 40 more months in prison, to run at the same time as his current sentence for more than a dozen securities fraud charge. Loebel had solicited investment funds from doctors, lawyers and business leaders but then used those funds to support his lavish lifestyle and gambling habit.
Jeffrey Lowrance, 51, has entered into a plea agreement relating to his $25 million Ponzi scheme that took in funds from more than 400 investors. Although the charges against him carry a maximum sentence of 40 years, the agreement recommends 12 ½ to 15 ½ years.
Kevin Mirecki, 53, of Los Angeles, California, was sentenced to 6 months in federal prison after pleading guilty to charges of failing to file his tax returns on reportedly more than $1.3 million in income. Mirecki founded Genesis Fund Ltd., which was an $80 million Ponzi scheme involving foreign currency and hundreds of investors.
Jeffrey L. Mowen was ordered to pay about $18 million pursuant to a judgment obtained by the SEC for his operation of a Ponzi schemes in concert with Thomas Fry. Fry raised over $40 million from more than 150 investors through the sale of supposed high-yield promissory notes. About $18 million of those funds was paid to Mowen, who misappropriated the funds rather than investing them.
Thomas Preston O’Berry of Georgia, was sentenced to two years in federal prison and ordered to pay $922,000 in restitution in connection with charges relating to an over $2.4 million Ponzi scheme that he ran through a company called MoGo Consulting LLC. O’Berry solicited investors into his software consulting business, promising a 10% return per month for money loaned for each purported consultant contract to alleviate cash flow problems. O’Berry never actually had any clients or contracts though. Instead, he fabricated 245 consultant contracts which generated investments of $2,480,000.
Eric Olson and Ted Olson were hit with a $15.2 million attachment by Park Construction. The court found that Eric and Ted Olson received nearly $10 million from KMO Associates, managed by Aaron Olson — apparently as returns on their investments, although Ted Olson had not placed any of his own money with KMO, and Eric Olson said he had invested $7 million of his own funds. Park Construction had invested more than $15 million with KMO and Aaron Olson — Eric Olson’s nephew. Based in part on negative inferences drawn from Aaron Olson’s invocation of his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, the Court noted that Eric Olson and Ted Olson were more than investors in KMO.
In connection with the Ponzi scheme of Daren Palmer and his company Trigon Group, a jury found that the head of the Bonneville County Republican Party, Doyle Beck of Pocatello Idaho, must return $55,000 of the $500,000 that he received from Trigon. Beck alleged at trial that the funds were repayment of a loan that he had made to Palmer’s brother-in-law, Duane Yost, which Yost repaid using Trigon’s money. Palmer was convicted last year in connection with what may be the largest Ponzi scheme in Idaho state history, involving about $75.8 million received from 68 investors between 2002 and 2008. The state of Idaho won a $27 million judgment against Yost last year in connection with Palmer’s scheme based on allegations that Yost brought more than $27 million of investor funds into Trigon.
Marc Perlman was charged by the CFTC with operating a Ponzi scheme through iGlobal Strategic Management in fraudulently soliciting at least $670,000 from about 17 people, supposedly to invest in foreign exchange and promising them profits of 10% per month. Perlman, who is deaf, targeting deaf evangelical Christians. He only invested about half of the funds and used the rest for charges at department stores, electronic stores, and for groceries, restaurants and rent.
Carmelo Provenzano, 29, and Daniel Dragan, 41, of New Jersey pleaded guilty to a $3.5 million Ponzi scheme. A third conspirator, George Sepero, has been indicted and is currently awaiting trial. They represented to investors that they owned hedge funds known as Caxton Capital Management and CCP Pro Consulting Inc. and that their trading program using a proprietary computer algorithm would generate returns of 170%. Dragan and Provenzano spent investor money on credit card bills averaging approximately $25,000 per month; bar tabs of $18,241—including a $4,000 tip—and $14,034 on separate nights at Drai’s Hollywood nightclub in Los Angeles; and flights to Paris and elsewhere. Provenzano bought a luxury Range Rover Sport SUV costing more than $71,000, with a down payment of more than $65,000.
Clifford Puterbaugh, 49, reportedly assisted by Kyle Higgins, 27, has been accused of running a Ponzi scheme that bilked $190,000 from at least three victims. Puterbaugh faces 28 charges ranging from aggravated theft to securities fraud. Higgins faces four charges ranging from securities fraud to sale of unregistered security.
Joseph D. Ransberger, 49, of Palm Beach Florida, and a previously convicted Ponzi schemer, has been charged with 105 new charges of grand theft and money laundering in a new scheme to allegedly defraud insurance premium finance companies to help pay for a lavish lifestyle. The new scheme was allegedly concocted after he was first arrested in June 2009 for a scheme in which he allegedly borrowed nearly $2 million dollars for insurance policies on entities that never existed. Ransberger is accused of allegedly misappropriating insurance premium funds between the date of his courtroom plea and his scheduled sentencing.
Rex Venture Group, a North Carolina company that operates ZeekRewards.com and Zeekler.com, was the subject of an emergency order obtained by the SEC to freeze its assets, including $225 million of investor funds that it still held. The principal of the company, Paul R. Burks, 65, is accused of raising approximately $600 million from more than 1 million customers through its penny auction website that appears to be a Ponzi scheme. ZeekRewards customers were offered several ways to earn money through the site, including buying unregistered investment contracts called “Retail Profit Pool” and the “Matrix” that promised a share of up to 50% of the company's net profits through rewards points that could be traded for cash payouts. ZeekRewards paid out nearly $375 million to investors and holds approximately $225 million in investor funds in 15 foreign and domestic financial institutions. It is alleged that Burks siphoned off up to $11 million dollars of investors’ funds and that he paid at least $1 million to family members.
Ricardo Rojas was charged in connection with a $7 million Ponzi scheme, run through his company Shadai Yire, which promised high returns of 15% to 50%, which were 100% guaranteed, to approximately 200 people in Puerto Rico, North Carolina, Florida and New York. Rojas said he was a commodities trader who would invest the funds through a subsidiary of Shadai Yire called M&R International Group. Rojas and his companies were not registered to sell securities. Rojas targeted evangelical Christians and factory workers in Puerto Rico, and he misappropriated about $700,000 of investor funds for his own personal use.
Francis X. Sanchez had his bond revoked while he awaits sentencing for his role in a $7 million Ponzi scheme which he ran with a partner through a company called InvestForClosures. Sanchez’s business partner, James D. Bourassa, was sentenced to 51 months in prison. The scheme involved representations to investors that they bought distressed houses, rehabilitated them, and sold them for a profit. The investments were supposedly backed by real estate, but there was not enough real estate to secure all of the investments. The court revoked the bond due to concern that Sanchez would not appear for future hearings.
Emanuel L. Sarris, 71, and his company, Sarris Financial Group, Inc. of Pennsylvania, were sued by the SEC in connection with a $100 million Ponzi scheme in which they solicited investors for the Kenzie Funds. The Kenzie Funds defrauded at least 400 investors worldwide out of over $100 million between 2001 and 2010. The SEC had already obtained a judgment against Kenzie and its principal, Illinois resident Daniel Spitzer. Sarris provided estate planning and insurance sales to investors through Sarris Financial and solicited over 70 clients to invest over $30 million with the Kenzie Funds. Sarris misrepresented to investors that he was independent of the Kenzie Funds, that his advice was unbiased and objective, that he had performed due diligence on the Kenzie Funds, and that he had personally seen the Funds' trading and banking records.
Arthur John Schlecht, 53, of North Carolina, Bart Gomer, 66, of Florida, Ricardo Jorge Padron, 52, and Carlos Rodriguez, both of Florida, were arraigned on charges of engaging in a conspiracy to commit fraud through their three corporations, Global Bullion Tracking Group, WJS Funding, d/b/a Capital Asset Management, and Certified Inc., d/b/a Certified Clearing. These businesses claimed to be investment brokerage firms offering investors the opportunity to invest in gold, silver, platinum, and palladium bullion, which would be stored for the investors in depository vaults. It is alleged that they never actually purchased any of the metal for the investors, but rather used the investors’ funds for their personal benefit, including expenditures by Schlect for maid services, personal tax obligations, salary, social security contributions, home and vacation home construction, landscaping, remodeling, interior furnishings, automobile purchase, restaurant dining, personal travel expenses, clothing and jewelry. Schlecht was the subject of a consent order from 1996 in connection with fraudulent activity through his company Concorde Trading Group in which Concorde traded over 2,800 accounts, over 90% of those customers lost all of substantially all of their money, and Concorde collected $12.8 million in commissions.
Joanne Schneider, 71, of Ohio was sentenced to 9 years after pleading guilty in connection with her $60 million Ponzi scheme where she promised investors 16 to 20% on their investments. She will get credit for 2½ years already served, reducing the time left to serve to 6½ years. Schneider sold unregistered promissory notes in connection with her real estate development projects. Schneider’s husband, Alan Schneider, played a lesser role in the scheme and was put on probation after pleading guilty in 2009. A receiver was appointed, who recovered $10.5 million for investors.
Jill Marie Silvey, 50, a former San Jose California real estate agent, has been accused of bilking at least 13 clients out of $1.2 million in a Ponzi scheme case between 2005 and 2011. Silvey allegedly took money from victims under the pretense that she was lending it to homeowners in exchange for monthly interest payments, but the homeowners were unaware about any loans. She is being held in jail on $3 million bail and faces more than 30 years in jail, if convicted. Silvey used the investors’ funds to buy expensive clothes, remodel her San Jose home, furnish it, and to purchase two luxury vehicles.
Weizhan Tang, a hedge fund manager who referred to himself as the “Chinese Warren Buffet,” and his companies, Oversea Chinese Fund and Weizhan Tang & Associates, have been ordered to disgorge more than $11.7 million in profits from a Ponzi scheme. Tang sold Chinese-American victims partnership interests in WinWin Limited Capital Partnership, a Texas-based entity. Tang collected $17.3 million from investors, about $9.6 million of which remains unaccounted for.
Daniel Thomas, 44, and his company, Key Business Solutions and Payroll Advisors in Florida, defrauded 7 clients who thought their money was going toward payment of payroll taxes to the IRS. Thomas created electronic taxpayer accounts for his clients and sent the IRS payments electronically. He then showed his clients that he made the payments by printing out the payment confirmation pages from the IRS, but then later cancelled the payments and transferred the money to his own business bank account. Thomas embezzled more than $850,000 and has been sentenced to 30 months in federal prison and ordered to pay $334,742.82 in restitution.
Michael J. Turncock, William P. Sullivan, and their company Bridge Premium Finance, LLC ("BPF") in Colorado were charged by the SEC in connection with a Ponzi scheme involving at least $15.7 million and more than 120 investors. Turncock and Sullivan were the principal and CFO of BPF, formally known as Berjac of Colorado, which promised investors an annual return of 12% and that their funds would be used to extend short-term loans to small businesses that would use the funds to pay up-front commercial insurance premiums. The investment was touted as 100% safe and protected by the “Colorado Insurance Guarantee Fund.
Doug Vaughan of Albuquerque, New Mexico, allegedly swindled 600 investors out of $75 million in at least eight states. Vaughan has been free since pleading guilty last year to mail and wire fraud charges, and his sentencing has been set for September 5, 2012.
Leesa Marie Ward, 47, and Alison Ann Jensen, 47, officers of Ward Real Estate, in California, were each sentenced to 3 years in San Joaquin County Jail in connection with a Ponzi scheme where there were losses of over $5.8 million collected from 33 victims. The bookkeeper of Ward Real Estate, Sharon Lee Graham, is scheduled for a preliminary hearing on October. Ward reportedly spent the money on parties, plastic surgery, and vehicles.
James Wiederhold, 39, was sentenced, along with his father, Neal Wiedrhold, 62, and uncle, Larry Niewenhuis, 55, in connection with a $1 million Ponzi scheme where he told victims he was the co-manager of Atlas Funds and that they were guaranteed 24% annual returns on their investments. Wiederhold was sentenced to 6 years plus 3 years of probation, restitution of $827,300, and forfeiture of $803,000. Neal Wiederhold was sentenced to 12 months and one day, plus two years supervised release, restitution. Niewenhuis was sentenced to 2 years plus 2 years of supervised release and restitution. Anthony Rinkus, 32, and Joseph Angioi were also named in the indictments. Rinkus was sentenced to 35 months imprisonment in July 2011 and Angioi was sentenced to 5 years probation in September 2011.
Ronnie Wilson, former South Carolina city councilman, pleaded guilty to charges that he operated a Ponzi scheme that bilked investors out of at least $60 million. Wilson operated Atlantic Bullion & Coin, Inc., ("ABC") from at least 2001 through 2012, telling investors they could expect above-average returns through profits earned from the purchase and sale of silver futures contracts. To convince investors of the scheme's legitimacy, Wilson represented that all silver purchased would be held in safe-keeping at a Delaware depository. In total, Wilson raised approximately $90 million from over 1000 investors in 25 states. However, Wilson failed to purchase a sufficient amount of silver to reflect the amount of funds raised from investors. Instead, a majority of investor funds were used for a variety of unauthorized purposes, including personal expenses of Wilson and his family and to make Ponzi-style payments representing fictitious interest to investors. Authorities estimate that Wilson lost at least $60 million of the $90 million raised from investors.
William Wise, 62, of North Carolina, has been sued for allegedly more than $1 million in back taxes on more than $3 million in unreported income in 2008. Wise operated Millenium Bank, billing it as a unit of a Swiss bank based on the Caribbean island of St. Vincent, and promised investors 16% returns on certificate of deposits. Millenium sold about $130 million of fraudulent certificates of deposits. Wise spent the investors’ dollars on a $12,000 weekly allowance for his wife, $6,000 to $10,000 a month each for his girlfriends, $1 million on wine, $800,000 to build an hangar in Atlanta for a corporate jet, $450,000 for three boats and an undetermined sum for a 2008 New Year's Eve party for 50 people on St. Vincent.
INTERNATIONAL PONZI SCHEME NEWS
Australia
The FBI and the Australian Federal Police seized more than $12 million in gold and silver bullion from an Australian account of James Fayed, 49, of Los Angeles, who is alleged to have run an international Ponzi scheme through e-Bullion.com. Fayed is currently on death row for contracting hitmen who murdered his wife. Fayed’s e-Bullion purported to provide investors opportunities to invest in precious metals, where investors opened accounts with real money, purchased virtual “e-currency” purportedly backed by precious metal reserves maintained by Fayed’s companies in the United States and Australia, and then could then trade their e-currency with others on the website. Prosecutors in the United States and Australian authorities worked closely together to recover a total of approximately $24 million in assets. A forfeiture judgment was signed which awarded to the United States approximately $3.6 million in bank funds and $5.4 million worth of gold, silver and platinum previously seized by the United States government.
Bangladesh
Retired Lieutenant General Harunur Rashid, former army chief and war hero in Bangladesh, and the president of Destiny Group, and 21 other senior officials of the group, have been charged by the Bangladesh's anti-graft agency with stealing $400 million from nearly two million investors through alleged Ponzi schemes. The Destiny Group allegedly collected 23.35 billion taka ($286 million) for a tree harvesting project. The other project was a credit society in which the Destiny Group collected deposits and said the money would be returned with a substantial rate of interest within a certain number of years. Destiny Group, with nearly 1.7 million investors, had been suspected by authorities of running Ponzi schemes since it was set up in 2000.
Canada
In the Canadian Ponzi scheme of Earl Jones, RBC Dominion Securities (RBC) and two brokers have been fined $700,000 for "failing in their duty to protect the financial markets" from Earl Jones' Ponzi scheme. The Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada approved the fines. Jones, an unlicensed financier from Montreal, is serving an 11-year prison term for masterminding a $35-million fraud that saw 158 people bilked of their life savings. RBC agreed to pay a $500,000 fine while brokers Serge Leclaire and Jean-Pierre Menard will pay $100,000 each. The deal addresses longstanding allegations from Jones' victims, who say RBC should have stopped Jones from gaining signing power over estates and emptying bank accounts for 25 years. In March, Royal Bank agreed to pay $17 million to settle a lawsuit filed by victims of Jones.
India
The emu business in India is suffering as one of the latest Ponzi schemes came to light with over 40,000 emus abandoned by several emu farm businesses, at least one of which was owned by MS Guru operating under the name Susi Emu Farms. Guru is now missing. Up to 20,000 investors have lost their money and between 40,000 and 1000,000 emus have been abandoned. Government officials are seizing the assets of five firms and watching 23 others, as they also try to locate a buyer for the emus.
Indonesia
A husband and wife team, identified as BR and DM, have been arrested in connection with a Ponzi scheme they ran under PT Koperasi Putera Pandawa, which involved Rp 500 million (US$63,600). About 1,300 investors were offered profits of 30% to 50%. The victims were told that they could withdraw their money from Idul Fitri savings accounts two weeks prior to the Idul Fitri holidays. The victims, mostly low and middle-income citizens, held BR and DM hostage when their money was not returned. The police disbursed the crowd, charged BR and DM with fraud and embezzlement, and seized the company’s computers and records.
Majorca
John Hirst, 61, Richard Pollett, 70, and Linda Hirst, 62, were convicted in connection with a £10 million Ponzi scheme that targeted UK investors and ex-pats in Majorca. The scheme operated under the name Gilher Inc. between 2001 and 2009, and investors were told that their money would be invested in the US stock market. They used £5 million of the funds to support their own lifestyles. John Hirst pleaded guilty of conspiracy to defraud and two counts of money laundering. Pollett, who was extradited from Spain, was found guilty of conspiracy to defraud, and Linda Hirst was found guilty of three counts of money laundering. John Hirst served a prison term in the early ‘90s for an investment fraud with similar characteristics to the Giher operation.
New Zealand
Jacqui Bradley is on trial in Auckland District Court for charges relating to a Ponzi scheme involving 28 investors who invested about $15 million. Bradley told investors that she was buying into New Zealand Government Stock or putting their money with Macquarie Bank, but instead used funds to buy an expensive home, and to pay her credit card bills and daughter’s school fees.
Poland
Prosecutors in Poland charged Marcin Plichta, 28, the owner of a suspended investment fund known as Amber Gold, in the gold-derivatives business, with illegal activity in connection with the collection of funds from up to tens of thousands of customers amounting to up to $24 million. The investors were promised up to 16% interest. Amber Gold owns OLT Express Poland, a Polish charter airline, formally known as Yes Airways, which suspended all charter services on July 31, 2012. An undisclosed amount of gold was seized during an inspection of the offices of Amber Gold and from private apartments.
South Africa
Herman Pretorious, a South African fund manager, is alleged to have shot and killed Julian Williams of Basileus Capital, a private equity firm, and then himself, in relation to an alleged Ponzi scheme involving investor losses of approximately $250 million. Pretorious operated the Relative Value Arbitrage Fund (RVAF) which purported to pay returns to investors of 20% to 30% and paid commissions to financial advisors of 7.5% to 12% to steer new business to RVAF. Pretorious led a lavish lifestyle, apparently using investor funds, and drove exotic cars, including an Aston Martin, and he owned two extravagant homes.
NEWSWORTHY LEGAL ISSUES IN PENDING PONZI SCHEME CASES
Irving Picard, Trustee of Bernard L. Madoff Securities, LLC, filed a lawsuit against New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman in Manhattan federal court to stop a settlement with former Madoff investor Ezra Merkin. New York had announced a settlement for $410 million with Merkin over claims that Merkin funds secretly placed client money with Bernard L. Madoff. The agreement provides $405 million to compensate investors and $5 million for the state. Picard contends that the settlement prejudices creditors and has asked the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Manhattan to block the settlement saying it interferes with his exclusive right to seek money for victims of Madoff's Ponzi scheme. Picard, who has been seeking more than $500 million from Merkin, says that New York should not have "a jump start over all of the victims of this heinous fraud." "It is clear that the remaining assets of the Merkin defendants will be insufficient to satisfy the trustee's claims. Such an outcome would be extraordinarily prejudicial to the creditors of the BLMIS estate."
Also in the Madoff case, Picard obtained court approval to make a second payment to customers that may approximate $2.4 billion. A hearing was held on Picard’s second distribution motion, and some customers had demanded 9% interest on their claims. The court ruled that Picard could reserve 3%, not the full 9% requested, pending final resolution of this issue, referred to as Time Based Damages, which means that he can distribute about $1 billion more than if he were required to reserve for the full 9% requested by customers.
The tax consequences of investing in the Madoff scheme continue. In New Jersey Tax Court, an investor’s estate, that of Theodore Warshaw, challenged taxes assessed against Warshaw’s IRA account, valued at $1,848,293, and holding securities worth $1,463,733. The estate paid estate tax of $88,677 and distributions were made in 2007 and 2008. But then the Madoff scheme broke in late 2008, and they learned that the IRA statements were entirely fictitious. Warshaw’s executors sought a refund of the estate taxes paid. Although the Ithaca Trust Rule provides that events following the decedent’s death should not be considered in calculating estate tax, the New Jersey Tax Court found that subsequent events can be considered to calculate the value of the asset at the time of death. The court found that later discovered information about the conditions at the time of valuation may be considered. In an ironic twist, the court noted that fair market value is determined by what a hypothetical buyer would have paid and that, here, a buyer would have conducted due diligence to discover there were not assets in the IRA. Of course, investors in the Madoff scheme, along with feeder funds, the SEC and everyone else, seemed to miss this fact, but this was probably the right result in this case anyway.
In the Arthur Nadel Ponzi scheme case, a court has dismissed many of the claims contained in a lawsuit filed by the receiver, Burton Wiand, against Wachovia Bank, which is now owned by Wells Fargo Bank. Wiand alleged that the bank had played an “essential” role in the Ponzi scheme and that the bank should have detected the scheme. Finding that the allegations did not meet the threshold of actual knowledge, the court dismissed the claims for aiding and abetting fraud, breach of fiduciary duty and conversion.
In the Nadel Ponzi scheme case, the law firm of Holland & Knight agreed to pay $25 million to settle claims against it brought by Burt Wiand, the receiver who is administering the case. Wiand had sued the firm for about $170 million, alleging malpractice and complicity in the scheme, alleging that the firm had missed red flags that would have exposed the fraud. The firm did not admit any wrongdoing in connection with the settlement. When the settlement is finalized, the receiver hopes to pay out an additional $20 million to investors, which would bring the amounts recovered to about 30 percent. Nadel had been found guilty of defrauding investors of $168 million. He died in prison in April of this year at the age of 80.
An investor in the Ponzi scheme of Gurudeo “Buddy” Persaud, the broker whose investment strategy was tied to lunar cycles, has sued Money Concepts Capital Corp., the brokerage firm that employed Persaud, accusing the firm of negligence.
The trustee in the Thomas Petters Ponzi scheme case won a $200,000 judgment against Luxembourg soccer club CS Fola Esch. The soccer club had received $200,000 from Petters in July 2008.
Also in connection with the Petters Ponzi scheme, a court has authorized the U.S. Attorney’s Office to seize a home linked to Petters in Minnesota with a value of about $580,000. The home was occupied by the ex-husband of a former Petters’ associate, Deanna Coleman.
And again in Petters Ponzi scheme, Roger Jenkins, dean of the business school at Miami University, has reached a settlement with the court-appointed receiver, to return $1.25 million in consulting fees that he had earned from Petters. Jenkins had obtained permission from the university to consult with Petters to help create the strategy to merge the management teams at Polaroid and Petters’ company and to develop strategy to develop the Polaroid brand for sale to a Chinese buyer.
In connection with the Ponzi scheme of Scott Rothstein, a U.S. District Judge ruled that ruled TD Bank and its counsel, Greenberg Traurig, violated rules regarding evidence produced in a lawsuit filed by investors in Rothstein's $1.2 billion scam. (see http://theponzibook.blogspot.com/2012/02/aiding-and-abetting-claims-against.html for an explanation of the lawsuit). The court found that the bank and law firm should pay Coquina Investments attorney fees and costs related to the sanctions motions. The amount will be decided later. The decision may have a larger impact, however, as the Court made findings of fact that the bank knew about the fraud scheme, participated in and had money laundering and fraud controls that were “unreasonable.” The court found: “I find that Greenberg Traurig acted negligently in failing to comply with its discovery obligations…, and TD Bank acted willfully in failing to comply with its discovery obligations and assist its outside counsel to properly litigate this case…” Coquina has filed a motion seeking attorney’s fees in the amount of $463,000.
Steven Hayworth, the former CEO of Gibraltar Private Bank & Trust, has agreed to settle a lawsuit filed in connection with the Scott Rothstein $1.4 billion Ponzi scheme. Hayworth was the founder of the bank but agreed to step down earlier this year in the face of allegations that Rothstein laundered money at the bank for years. The trustee of Rothstein’s law firm, Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler, had already filed and settled a lawsuit involving the bank and three former officers, leading to a payment of at least $15 million from Gibraltar and the right to sue the bank’s insurance carriers for coverage valued at another $35 million.
In the bankruptcy case of the $140 million Ponzi scheme of Frederick Darren Berg and Meridian Funds, which involved more than 750 investors, the trustee, Mark Calvert, has filed a lawsuit against Berg and Moss Adams. Calvert contends that that Berg, with the “knowledge and assistance” of Moss Adams, engaged in the fraudulent activity. Moss Adams has contended that it only audited a few of the Meridian funds for a short period of time and that investors did not put their money into the funds because of Moss Adams’ audits.
In the R. Allen Stanford Ponzi scheme, the SEC has appealed the district court’s ruling that the SIPC, which insures U.S. brokerage accounts, does not have to cover the losses of the Stanford victims. The scheme was a $7 billion Ponzi scheme, and victims now continue to hold out hope that they will receive money from SIPC. The SEC had sought a court order to compel SIPC to cover losses of Stanford victims, but the court ruled against the SEC in July, finding that the SEC had not met its burden in proving that the victims of the Ponzi scheme constitute victims eligible for compensation by the SIPC, under the narrow definition of the law.